Home Blog Page 133

WHO did NOT rank Nigeria 4th best in COVID-19 response

0

Many media reports claimed that the World Health Organization (WHO) has ranked Nigeria as the 4th best in COVID-19 response.

These media reports which are archived here, here and was also published by the Nigerian embassy in Sweden all attributed the claim to WHO Country Representative in Nigeria, a doctor, Walter Mulombo.

According to reports, Mulombo made the statement at an event on the arrival of the first consignment of 177,600 doses of the Johnson and Johnson (J&J) COVID-19 vaccine in Abuja.

“We are witnessing the symbolic arrival of 177,600 Johnson & Johnson vaccines, another landmark event in Nigeria’s response to COVID-19 pandemic; widely acclaimed by many as one of the most successful so far in the world.

“Nigeria was ranked fourth among the top ten most successful responses to COVID-19,” the statement attributed to Mulombo read.


Read also:


In a swift reaction, the Buhari Media Organisation (BMO), a group that supports and attempt to court goodwill for Nigeria’s President Muhammadu Buhari celebrated the news, saying his fight against the pandemic was what necessitated the ranking.

In a statement signed by BMO Chairman, Niyi Akinsiju and Secretary Cassidy Madueke, BMO noted President Buhari’s determination to safeguard the lives of Nigerians and residents alike during the pandemic

“We also note that President Muhammadu Buhari did not spare any resource in ensuring that the Presidential Task Force on COVID-19 carried out its responsibilities without let or hindrance,” their statement react.

WHO debunks the claim

In a bid to verify the claim that Nigeria ranked 4th best in COVID-19 response, The FactCheckHub checked the WHO website but found nothing of such.

The FactCheckHub, however, reached out to the WHO spokesperson in Nigeria Charity Warigon, who clarified the issue.

“I wish to clarify that, WHO has not ranked countries in relation to COVID-19 response,” says Warigon.

2nd right, WHO Country Representative, Walter Mulombo at the arrival of Johnson & Johnson vaccine in Nigeria. Photo: WHO/Ogbeide E.

Warigon in a telephone conversation with The FactCheckHub said what the country representative meant was that the country was efficient in handling COVID-19

“The WHO Representative [Walter Mulombo] meant to say Nigeria mounted one of the most effective response to COVID-19, putting in place courageous measures and helping to avert the widespread that was predicted,” she added.

She added that “Some independent media analysis had previously presented a ranking for top 10 countries including Nigeria appearing on 4th position. It should be noted however that this is not a WHO ranking.”

In addition when WHO reported the same event on their website, archived here, the statement about the ranking was not including.

THE VERDICT

The claim that WHO ranked Nigeria 4th best in COVID-19 response is inaccurate and MISLEADING, the WHO communication officer in Nigeria said the ranking did not emanate from the organisation.

COVID-19: Claims about transmission via water, vaccine death toll fact-checked

AS the world battle ongoing concerns around COVID-19 vaccine safety, side effects, vaccine hesitancy and refusal, a Twitter user posted that reports related to vaccine deaths are hushed.

The tweet which has over 470 engagements posted in July 2021 and archived here read “Have you noticed how quickly they report a death as a COVID-19 death, but ever so reluctant to tell us when a vaccine kills someone?”

The post generated comments with some alleging vaccines damages the immune system and another, alleging the virus with reference to the Lambda variant “is spreading fast” via water.

Does COVID-19 spread via water?

At the onset of the pandemic, there were fears and concerns that COVID-19 spread through water as such swimming wasn’t safe. However, the number one health body, the World Health Organizations (WHO) noted that the fears were unfounded.

Poster by the WHO.

The WHO clarified  “Water or swimming does not transmit the COVID-19 virus”.

It further explained that “The COVID-19 virus does not transmit through water while swimming. However, the virus spreads between people when someone has close contact with an infected person.”

As such there was a need to maintain social distance from others while swimming and “wear a mask when you’re not in the water and you can’t stay distant”, this is in addition to adhering to other COVID-19 protocols.

This was also repeated on WHO South-East Asia.

Poster by the WHO.

The COVID-19 variants

Viruses change over time. The COVID-19 virus which is caused by SARS-CoV-2 is no different.  Most Changes have negligible or no impact on the virus properties however some changes might  affect how “it spreads, the associated disease severity, or the performance of vaccines” says The WHO.

To keep track of the changes in COVID-19 virus the Greek Alphabet was adopted. As of July 2021, the variant is at the 11th alphabet which is the Lambda.

However, this variant is not on the WHO’s Virus of Concern (VOCs) list but rather on the Virus of Interest (VOIs) list.

The emergence of variants that posed an increased risk to global public health are classed under the  VOCs, this is in order to prioritise global monitoring and research, and ultimately to inform the ongoing response to the COVID-19 pandemic says WHO.

Alpha, Beta, Gamma and Delta are the currently the VOCs while Epsilon, Zeta, Eta , Theta, Iota, Kappa and Lambda are  VOIs

Even though Lambda is considered to have a  potentially increased transmissibility, this spread was not noted to be via water.

… on vaccines deaths

As of August 5, 2021, the total number of COVID-19 cases worldwide surpassed 200 million, including over four million deaths, this was just six months after reaching 100 million cases.

Whereas as of 12 August 2021, the cumulative number of vaccine doses which have been administered surpassed 4.4 billion.

There have been several conspiracy theories and concerns that the vaccines are resulting to deaths and these deaths are high, hushed or not reported enough.  Debunking one of such claims the U.S. Deputy director for Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s Immunization Safety Office Tom Shimabukuro said it inaccurate to equate death after vaccine as caused by the vaccine.

The doctor noted that “Statements that imply that deaths following vaccination equate to deaths caused by vaccination are scientifically inaccurate, misleading, and irresponsible.”


Read also:


A look at the multiple variations of such claims in circulation show that they were hinged albeit wrongly on data gotten from a U.S. government database called VAERS (Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System) where anyone in the U.S. can report adverse effects after receiving a vaccine.

A  verification done in June on a series of posts claiming that the number of deaths related to vaccines may soon rival the number of deaths from COVID-19 are false according to  a verification done by Reuters , as the “the large number wrongly described as ‘vaccine-related deaths’ in a series of online posts is the total number of reports that were made on  VAERS”.

Another of such claim that the “death toll” of COVID-19 vaccines is more than 20 times higher than that of past vaccines was also found to be inaccurate.

There was also the claim attributed to a “whistleblower” that the  administration of U.S. President Joe Biden is covering up at least 45,000 vaccine-related deaths this was also found to be inaccurate.

Similar claims were widely shared on Tiktok that there are tens of thousands of unreported deaths from the COVID-19 vaccine this was also found to be inaccurate by the BBC as it misrepresented data from the VAERS website.

Why the misrepresentation?

COVID-19 vaccines have a broader reporting requirement on VAERS as healthcare providers are expected to report all serious adverse health events, even if the provider does not think the vaccine caused that event.

These events can include death, inpatient hospitalisation among others. This reporting protocol is because the FDA authorised the COVID-19 vaccines for emergency use, USA Today reports.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) also clarified that the reports of adverse events to VAERS following vaccination, including deaths, do not necessarily mean that a vaccine caused a health problem.

This publication was produced as part of IWPR’s Africa Resilience Network (ARN) programme, administered in partnership with the Centre for Information Resilience (CIR), the International Centre for Investigative Reporting  (ICIR), and Africa Uncensored

Viral photo of road shared on social media not from Kaduna but Pakistan

0

A TWITTER user on Friday August 13, 2021 shared a picture of a tarred road claiming it emanated from Kaduna State in Nigeria.

The Twitter user with the handle @Mamatee001 in a tweet archived here said the road was constructed  by Kaduna State governor Nasir El-Rufai.Kad

The tweet read “This is not Canada but Kaduna. A road constructed by that man u hate @elrufai he is not sharing kerosene neither Is he giving wheel barrow but building future. A leader who excel even when some evil are bent in destroying his government. A great Man to study like encyclopedia.”

THE CLAIM

Picture shows tarred road  in Kaduna state.

A screenshot of the tweet.

THE FINDINGS

Checks by The FactCheckHub show that the picture emanated from Pakistan and not Kaduna as claimed by the twitter user.


Read also:


A Google reverse image search conducted by The FactCheckHub shows the image was on the internet before.

Similarly, a Google earth imagery search conducted by The FactCheckHub revealed that the picture is that of Hazara Motorway in Pakistan.

The google earth imagery picture of the Hazara Motorway.

Hazara Motorway, otherwise known as M-15 Motorway is a 180-kilometre controlled-access road motorway linking Brhan interchange near Hassan Abdal in Punjab province with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province.

The road starts from Havelian and ends at Thakot.

THE VERDICT

The picture of tarred road shared by a Twitter user was constructed in Pakistan and not Kaduna thereby making the claim FALSE

 

FactCheckHub masterclass on identifying, debunking misinformation

0

To commemorate its one year anniversary, The FactCheckHub held a verification masterclass.

The masterclass titled, “How to identify and debunk misinformation,” took place on Zoom and Facebook on Tuesday, August 10, 2021.

Below is a recording of the session.

Thank you for watching. Kindly share with your friends!

MasterClass: How to identify and debunk misinformation

0

To commemorate its one year anniversary, The FactCheckHub held a verification masterclass.

The masterclass titled, “How to identify and debunk misinformation,” took place on Zoom and Facebook on Tuesday, August 10, 
2021.Here’s a recording of the session.

Website offering commonwealth scholarship is a scam, here is why

0

The Commonwealth is offering scholarships, however, a misleading website is being circulated on WhatsApp.

This is a trend observed by The FactCheckHub overtime whereby scammers and phishers ride on the back of legitimate projects to carry out their activities.

The post circulating on WhatsApp read in part “Apply for United Kingdom Scholarship 2021,  Fully funded scholarship to study for free in UK”, this was accompanied with a link that redirects to this website “Uk-scholarship.get-noww.xyz”.

The misleading post as circulated on WhatsApp.

The landing page of the website is riddled with grammatical, spelling errors as well as American spelling, this is a red flag because a commonwealth scholarship website which is funded by United Kingdom and targets applications from countries under the former  British empire would be using the British spelling of ‘programme’, instead of ‘program’ as was obtainable and so on.

This and other grammatical errors can be spotted across all the pages on the website.

The homepage of the misleading website riddled with errors.

Another red flag from the landing page is the non-clickable social media icons. The social media icons on  a website are supposed to redirect to the website’s social media handles when clicked, however this was not the case.

In addition, the page has a testimonial or user comments page that has a Facebook like comment interface,  however the commenters profile,  just like the icons, were not clickable too.

Furthermore, after filling the form, a prompt to share the website link to a number of whatsApp individuals or groups appears. This is one of the characteristics of scam and phishing websites observed by The FactCheckHub in a report about scam websites in Nigeria.

A common feature observed on phishing and misleading websites debunked by The FactCheckHub.

The FactCheckHub had earlier noted in a report here on how to spot and avoid such scam websites.

Twitter partners news platforms to tackle misinformation

0

IN a bid to tackle misinformation on its micro-blogging platform, Twitter has partnered with two international news platforms, the Associated Press (AP) and Reuters.

Making the announcement in a blog post, Twitter stated that the collaboration will help the platform in identifying and elevating credible information.

“We are committed to making sure that when people come to Twitter to see what’s happening, they are able to easily find reliable information.”

Social media platforms have been making conscious efforts in tackling misinformation, particularly in curbing elections and COVID-19 related ones.


READ ALSO:


Twitter in January launched Birdwatch, a community-based approach to tackle misinformation.

The Birdwatch allows people to identify information in Tweets they believe is misleading and write notes to give informative context on it.

Twitter, however, added that this new partnership will help provide veracious context to wide range of issues on the platform.

“Twitter will be able to expand the scale and increase the speed of our efforts to provide timely, authoritative context across the wide range of global topics and conversations that happen on Twitter every day,”

FactCheckHub set to host masterclass to commemorate 1st anniversary

0

IN commemoration of its one year anniversary, The FactCheckHub is set to host a verification masterclass.

The matersclass titled, “How to identify and debunk misinformation,” will take place on Zoom and Facebook on Tuesday, August 10, 2021.

Registration for the masterclass which is FREE and open to all can be done via here.

Established in 2020, The FactCheckHub is an initiative of the International Centre for Investigative Reporting (The ICIR) aimed at combatting misinformation in the society.

Since it launching in August of 2020, The FactCheckHub has verified  claims across varied subjects and even coutside the shores of Nigeria. The Fact-Checks can be read here are also amplified in multiple languages.

The FactCheckHub is a non-partisan platform for fact-checking with the primary aim of combating misinformation, disinformation, hoaxes and rumours about topical issues including COVID-19, elections, health and governance, among others.

Speaking on the masterclass,  Bamas Victoria, the Editor and Team Lead of The FactCheckHub stated that the masterclass, which is free, poised to empower the participants with basic fact-checking skills.

“In this age, the traditional media no longer have monopoly of technology for multiplying and distribution of news as was obtainable in the past, this simply means this hitherto exclusive access has now been extended to anyone with a phone and access to the internet.

The downside of this development is the infodemic – people are constantly faced with information from multiple sources. And because everyone now have access to share information online, misinformation and disinformation thrive; this has contributed to the reason why ‘fake news’ has become a buzzword and why media and independent fact-checking organisations are springing up to help combat and checkmate this trend. “

She added that all hands must be on deck in combating misinformation and in ensuring only factual information trends whether online or offline.

“However, this is not enough. All hands need to be on deck in combating misinformation. Therefore, the ability and skills to be able to discern what is factual and what is not is now a necessity for individuals in this global age.”

Opeyemi Kehinde, the Deputy Editor and Amplification Lead and Olugbenga Adanikin, a Researcher, Investigative journalist and Fact-Checker host the classes.

Interested participants can register here.

 

What sentence does conspiracy to commit fraud attracts in U.S.?

ON THURSDAY, July 29, 2021, social media was abuzz in Nigeria following a warrant of arrest  issued against a Deputy Commissioner of Nigerian Police Abba Kyari after his indictment in the ongoing fraud trial of Nigerian Ramon Olorunwa Abbas, known as Hushpuppi, in the United States.

The news published here, here and here stated the  warrant was issued on July 26 by Otis Wright, a judge in the United States District Court for the Central District of California.

Kyari was said to have been bribed by Hushpuppi to have Chibuzo Vincent, one of his associates, arrested and jailed in Nigeria following a dispute over a $1.1 million fraud of a Qatari businessperson.

Although, Kyari has denied the allegation on his Facebook Page but a Twitter user with username @Truthfully83 claimed that Kyari faces a charge that attracts 20 years in prison if found guilty.

The tweet partly reads: “Conspiracy to commit fraud in the United States, carries a statutory maximum sentence of 20 years in a federal prison. Sorry, Super cop Abba Kyari, you are about to embark on a long journey,” his tweet read.

THE CLAIM

Conspiracy to commit in U.S carries a statutory maximum sentence of 20 years.

A screenshot of the tweet.

THE FINDINGS

It was noted in a 66-page charge sheet prepared by the U.S District Court seen by The FactCheckHub that  Kyari, Hushpuppi and four others are being charged with “Conspiracy to Commit Wire Fraud” and “Conspiracy to Engage in Money Laundering”.

“Accordingly, there is probable cause to believe that ABBAS, JUMA, CHIBUZO, KYARI, FASHOLA, and AGBABIAKA committed violations of 18 U.S.C. § 1349 (Conspiracy to Commit Wire Fraud) and 18 U.S.C. § 1956(h) (Conspiracy to Engage in Money Laundering),”  the charge sheet read in part.

What the United States law says

According to the 18 U.S.C. § 1349 of the US law, a person has committed a wired fraud when he or she uses “wired communications as part of a scheme to defraud involving a material deception with the intent to deprive another of money, property, or honest services.”

It also stated that conspiracy to commit wire fraud occurs when two or more people connive to defraud another person of money, property, or honest services and interstate wired communications are used in perpetrating the crime.


READ ALSO:


According to U.S. federal law, wired fraud is classified as a class C felony, which attracts up to twenty years in prison, three years of supervised release and $250,000 in fines.

It read “Under federal law, the crime of Wire Fraud is a Class C felony, punishable by up to twenty years in prison, three years of supervised release, and $250,000 in fines. Additionally, complete restitution will be ordered and any property obtained from the proceeds of the offense will be confiscated.”

On the order hand, the second charge against Kyari, Husspuppi and the four others, which is, conspiracy to engage in money laundering attracts a fine of $500,000 or twice the value of the property involved in the transaction or imprisonment of not more than twenty years or both.

THE VERDICT

The claim that the conspiracy to commit fraud  in the United States carries a statutory maximum sentence of 20 years is TRUE, it, however, also attracts up to three years of supervised release and $250,000 in fines.

Fake News: Lai Mohammed seeks partnership with Nigerians in Diaspora

AS part of efforts to check the spread of fake news, the Minister of Information and Culture Lai Mohammed, on Tuesday, sought partnership with the Nigerians in Diaspora Organisation (NIDO).

The partnership seek to make factual information available as a way of countering the false narratives projected by some Nigerians abroad.

Mohammed made the call in Abuja during a courtesy visit by members of NIDO, UK Chapter, to his office.

“As an organised and well-connected group, I implore NIDO to leverage its contacts in government circles, parliamentary groups, and global think tanks in world capitals to help change the narrative and sweep the carpet off the feet of secessionist groups, insurgents, and anarchists who are bent on pushing false narratives to portray Nigeria in a bad light.”

“’I have no doubt that you will take this call seriously and do everything in your power to change the narrative for the better,” he said.

However, describing NIDO’s role as imperative to fighting misinformation about the country, he noted that as critical stakeholders, the responsibilities could be carried out through supports from the Nigerians in Diaspora Commission (NIDCOM).

The Minister said as part of deliberate efforts to counter anti-government propaganda, which is aimed at drowning the country, the government is scaling up diplomatic efforts to reverse the trend.

Did Lai Mohammed say the Igbos are responsible for Nigeria’s underdevelopment?

“On our part as government, we are currently re-engineering and ramping up our diplomatic efforts to counter and reverse the narrative, in addition to countering pervasive anti-government propaganda,” he said.

The Chairman, NIDO, UK Chapter, Chibuzo Ubochi, called on the National Assembly to fast track the passage of the bill that would enable Nigerians in Diaspora to vote and be voted for during elections, in view of their numerous contributions to the Nigerian economy.