Home Blog Page 146

Ezekwesili, others mull new approach against fake news

NIGERIA’s former Minister of Education, Dr Oby Ezekwesili, on Wednesday, disclosed the need to consider motivating purveyors of factual information, through incentives as a way of discouraging the spread of fake news.

Ezekwesili made the call during a webinar jointly organised by the International Centre for Investigative Reporting (ICIR) with the International Center for Journalists (ICFJ) Knight Fellowship in Nigeria.

The maiden edition held last year had the Minister of Youths and Sports Development, Sunday Dare, as the keynote speaker.

In her keynote address at the conference themed, Public Accountability in Stemming Misinformation,’ Ezekwesili said aside from the incentives, such a system would also reduce the credibility of those notorious for sharing misinformation.

The initiative is to be developed through collaborations with the public and media, and the group would determine the trust points as well as indicators on how the trust should be measured, she noted.

For every solution, we must consider for reducing or ensuring people are accountable for fake news, we need to think incentive and disincentive based approach. That is an approach that rewards a record of consistent dissemination of facts, truth.

That system that makes a person a purveyor of accurate information, especially those with strong followers and are sufficient to influence what others may think or do.

“The system would also deduct trust points in case unverified news are disseminated by the newsmakers or social media influencers.”

According to her, “the erosion of trust points overtime will signify a red flag anytime news comes from such individual or individuals.”

Besides, the former World Bank vice president, Africa region, identified the need to overwhelm ‘the market of news’ with accurate, evidence-based reporting. The continuous publication of factual information, she said, would overshadow false information.

While she spoke on being mindful of the inalienable right of the freedom of information of the people, in the guise of fighting fake news, the media is expected to perform its education function, thus teach the public in the simplest, plain language.

In the area of legislation, Ezekwesili kicked against the proposed social media bill, saying it would only repress the people. She tasked the relevant government institutions to remain alive to their responsibilities as there is an existing law that addresses issues of defamation, libel and the likes.

Earlier, the Executive Director of The ICIR, Dayo Aiyetan, said while holding people who deliberately post fake news to account, there is the need to look at the responsibility of the ordinary man who tends to look at misinformation warfare.

Citing Femi Fani-Kayode, a former Aviation Minister, as an instance, he said the politician had discouraged people from taking the COVID-19 vaccine through unverifiable assertions that it was meant to depopulate Africa. Still, the same minister recently took the COVID-19 vaccine.

The FactCheckHub, he said, has been deliberate in creating explainer videos, and training people to make everyone a fact-checker.

He also called for collective responsibilities from the government, Civil Society Organisations, stakeholders and the important role of the general public to check the spread of misinformation.

“We need to increasingly look at the responsibility of the ordinary man who becomes the weapon to use in the misinformation warfare. At the end of today, we hope we will have sensitized the public to combat misinformation.

“It is not the job of the government, civil society and the media alone. Everyone must be involved.”


The executive director/ editor-in-chief of Daily Trust newspapers, Naziru Mikail Abubakar, shared similar positions with Aiyetan and the former minister.

But, in his remarks, he encouraged both the legacy media and digital media to take active participation in combating misinformation.

The digital media organisations, he said, have bigger responsibilities to play.

Abubakar advised on the need for journalists’ training, media collaborations, investigative journalism, fact-checking, and self-examination.

Beyond media training initiated by local and international Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs), he tasked local media with best practices, stressing the need to set up a dedicated fund for the capacity building of journalists.

He also advised journalists to get the right modern tools.

Abubakar, who called for more investigative reporting encouraged local fact-checking organisations to increase fact-checking efforts, rather than republishing verified claims published by international fact-checking organisations.

“Government officials are making false statements. Some of these are false claims that should be fact-checked. If it is difficult to do individually, media organizations should collaborate with each other to make this possible.”

The Executive Director, Centre for Democracy and Development (CDD), Idayat Hassan, expressed worry on how fake news could impact the nation’s democracy.

She observed the benefits of social media as a tool that enabled the people to influence government policies, gave voices to the marginalised, but it is something that requires more attention.

Examining the difference between misinformation and disinformation, she highlighted the deliberate intent of the purveyor.

“The automation in disinformation in Nigeria is huge with 19.5 per cent. And the tools used include Nairaland, Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp and the recent one is Opera News.” She said.

However, in providing a lasting solution against the menace, Hassan advised the use of audio, picture, video to spread factual information. Beyond these, she also identified the adoption of local languages.

“There is a need to construct an informal structure that would resonate with the people.”

The founder of BudgIT, Seun Onigbinde, was the last panellist. In his topic titled, Digital Advocacy and Public Enlightenment on Social Media, he also described fake news as an extension of malicious reporting.

In the process, he explained the dynamism and how people react to information on each of the social media platforms, such as Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, WhatsApp.

Describing the distinctiveness as ‘spirit of the medium’, he advised media firms to shut down trolls.

In addition, Onigbinde urged the tech giants to design special algorithms that could discourage fake news, as well as spotting and delegitimising its purveyors.

He said there is a need for more advocacy for the tech giants to play an important role in addressing fake news.

Ezekwesili, other panellists at ICIR, ICFJ webinar mull new approach against fake news

0

Nigeria’s former Minister of Education Dr Oby Ezekwesili says there’s a need to consider motivating purveyors of factual information through incentives to discourage the spread of fake news.

Ezekwesili made the call during a webinar jointly organised by the International Centre for Investigative Reporting (ICIR) and the International Center for Journalists (ICFJ) Knight Fellowship in Nigeria.

How to archive posts for future reference

There are several reasons why you may want to keep a post or content you saw online for future reference.

One of such reasons is if you are fact-checking claims made by people.

It has been argued that sharing a direct link to a false claim made on social media in your report is giving publicity and traction to the user who shared the misinformation or disinformation.

To solve this conundrum, it’s better you archive the post.

There are different platforms that offer archiving services.

One of such is the  Wayback Machine. This is a digital archive of the World Wide Web, founded by the Internet Archive, a nonprofit library based in San Francisco, United States. It is a web archiving tool, which is a repository of stored information. It does this by taking snapshots of web pages.

Archive Today is also another time capsule for web pages. It takes a ‘snapshot’ of a webpage so that it can still be online even if the original page disappears or is deleted.

“It saves a text and a graphical copy of the page for better accuracy and provides a short and reliable link to an unalterable record of any web page,” it noted on its homepage.

To use Archive Today, here are the steps:

    1. Visit archive.is through the address bar of your internet browser.
    2. Copy the URL (website link) of the post you want to archive and paste in the red bar provided for it.
    3. Then, click Save.
The homepage for Archive Today.

4. Hold on while it saves the page. This will take a few minutes.

5. Once the archiving is completed, it will display a notification page.

An archived tweet for tutorial purpose only.

How to retrieve an archived post

To retrieve a saved post on the Wayback Machine:

  1. Visit archive.org through your web browser (Mozilla, Internet Explorer, Google Chrome, etc)
  2. Enter the URL or internet web link of the post to the address bar of the Wayback machine (e.g https://twitter.com/NNPCgroup/)
  3. Click on browse.
  4. A calendar will be displayed and the date(s) the post was archived highlighted.
  5. Click on the highlighted date. It will display the archive post.
  6. Alternatively, if you do not have the URL you can use keywords to search.
The highlighted date on a calendar showing when a post was archived.

Ezekwesili, others headline ICIR, ICFJ Knight Fellowship webinar on misinformation

0

The International Centre for Investigative Reporting (ICIR) in conjunction with the ICFJ Knight Fellowship in Nigeria will on Wednesday, March 31st, 2021, hold a webinar on stemming misinformation.

This is in keeping with the The ICIR interest in dispelling misinformation which led to setting up its fact-checking operation The FactCheckHub.

Dr. Oby Ezekwesili, former Minister of Education, and former Vice President for the World Bank, Africa region, would deliver the keynote address of the conference themed, “Public Accountability in Stemming Misinformation.”

The panelists scheduled to speak at the conference include Naziru Mikail Abubakar, the Executive Director/Editor-in-Chief of Daily Trust newspapers, Idayat Hassan, Executive Director of the Centre for Democracy and Development (CDD) and Oluseun Onigbinde, Founder of BudgIT.

Intending participants are expected to register for the webinar, which will commence  12 noon via this link.

Hannah Ajakaiye, the ICFJ Knight fellow for Nigeria who will moderate the event, said the webinar will curate discussions around combating the misinformation pandemic and galvanize citizens to advocate for good governance.

She added that, the event will arm the citizens with ideas on how they can promote public accountability through fight against misinformation and disinformation.

“The virtual event promises to be a well-rounded discussion intellectual guaranteed to provide possible solutions and ideas on how citizens can promote public accountability by owning the fight against misinformation and disinformation in the Nigerian society”, she noted

In 2020 the ICIR and the ICFJ hosted a similar webinar where the Minister of Youth and Sports, Sunday Dare delivered the keynote speech.

 

FG is NOT giving out COVID-19 ‘survival fund grant

0

A VIRAL post circulating on WhatsApp claims the Federal Government of Nigeria is giving out COVID-19 survival fund grant.

According to the broadcast message retrieved on March 25, 2021, the Federal Government of Nigeria will give N30,000 to successful applicants.

It reads:

[sic] DON’T MISS ANOTHER FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SURVIVAL FUND GRANT

The Federal Government have reopended the Survival Fund Portal

Check if You are Eligible to receive ₦30,000

As Part of SURVIVAL FUND GRANT

THE CLAIM

The Federal Government is giving out N30,000 COVID-19  survival fund grant.

A screenshot of the claim as shared on WhatsApp.

THE FINDINGS

Findings by the FactCheckHub show that the claim is FALSE.

SEE ALSO: Again, False claim circulates that Nigerian Government is giving out N10,500 weekly COVID-19 support

The FactCheckHub observed that the website in the broadcast post is different from the website specified for survival fund set up by the Federal Government of Nigeria for the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME).

The official survival fund website is https://survivalfund.gov.ng/

The FactCheckHub also observed that the website is a phishing website that seeks to gain traffic by prompting people to share on WhatsApp groups.

The FactCheckHub has in the past written on how people can spot such phishing ploys and websites.

You can also watch the tutorial video below.

Read also: Nigerian govt is not giving out N10,500 weekly COVID-19 support

THE VERDICT

The claim that the Federal Government is giving out N30,000 COVID-19 second wave survival fund is FALSE. The url (link) attached to the claim directs to a phishing website.

 

 

Samia Hassan Suluhu NOT first female president in East Africa

VIRAL posts on Thursday, March 18, 2021, claimed that Samia Hassan Suluhu, who is set to become Tanzania’s next president, would be the first female president in East Africa.

Following the death of Tanzanian president, John Pombe Magufuli, who was elected in 2015, Suluhu is now set to be sworn in as president but several posts on social media claimed that the woman would be the first female president in East Africa when finally sworn in.

A Nigerian Twitter Influencer, JJ. Omojuwa with the username @Omojuwa, who has over 1 million followers tweeted that Hassan set to become the first female president in East Africa.

A claim made on Twitter that Samia Hassan will be become the first female President in the East Africa region.

 

His tweet read: “Samia Suluhu Hassan will be Tanzania‘s next President. She will complete Magufuli’s term which ends in 2025. This will make her the first female President in East Africa. We wish Tanzania a peaceful transition.”

A Ugandan journalist also tweeted the same claim, which now has over 13000 likes and 4884 retweets on her wall as of 5pm on Thursday.

Two separate newspapers, Ripples Nigeria and Kenya-based Standard media also published the news with the same claim.

“East Africa to have its first female President in Tanzania’s Samia Suluhu Hassan,” read the standardmedia headline.

THE CLAIM

From the post, the following claims were established:

  1. Samia Hassan Suluhu will be Tanzania‘s next president.
  2. Samia Hassan Suluhu would be the first female president in East Africa.

THE FINDINGS

CLAIM 1: Samia Hassan Suluhu will be Tanzania‘s next president

The FactCheckHub findings revealed that the claim is TRUE

According to section 37 subsection 5 of the constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania of 1977, the vice-president would be sworn-in when the president dies. The constitution reads:

Where the office of President becomes vacant by reason of the death of the President, his resignation, loss of the electoral qualifications or inability to perform his functions due to physical infirmity, or failure to discharge the duties and functions of the office of President, then the Vice-President shall be sworn in and become the President for the unexpired period of the term of five years and in accordance with the conditions set out in Article 40, then after consultation with the political party to which he belongs, the President shall propose the name of the person who shall be Vice-President and such appointment shall be confirmed by the National Assembly by votes of not less than fifty percentum of all Members of Parliament.

Samia Hassan Suluhu, the Tanzanian vice-president had earlier announced the death of President John Magufuli, who died at the age of 61.

By virtue of the country’s constitution, Samia Hassan Suluhu will be sworn in as the president to complete Magufuli’s tenure, which ends by 2025.

CLAIM 2: Samia Hassan Suluhu would be the first female president in East Africa

The FactCheckHub findings revealed that the claim is FALSE.

The FactCheckHub research revealed that Sylvie Kinigi served as Prime Minister of Burundi from 10 July 1993 to 7 February 1994, and later as acting President from 27 October 1993 to 5 February 1994.

Burundi is in East Africa.

Monique Ohsan Bellepeau was another female president that had ruled an East African country before; she was a Mauritian politician and was Vice President of Mauritius from November 2010 to April 2016.

She became acting President of Mauritius from 31 March 2012 to 21 July 2012 when Sir Anerood Jugnauth resigned up to the inauguration of Kailash Purryag to the office.

She was again acting President from 29 May 2015 to 5 June 2015 when Kailash Purryag resigned up to the inauguration of Ameenah Gurib to the office.

Aside women who were acting president, East Africa also has Ameenah Gurib as  president of Mauritius.

Gurib served as the 6th President from 2015 to 2018.

Also, Joyce Hilda Banda was the President of   Malawi from 7 April 2012 to 31 May 2014.

In addition, Sahle-Work Zewde is the incumbent President of Ethiopia.

She was elected president unanimously by members of the Federal Parliamentary Assembly on 25 October 2018.

THE VERDICT

The claim that Samia Hassan Suluhu will be Tanzania‘s next president is TRUE. By the virtue of the country’s constitution, she should automatically be sworn in following the death of the former president.

The claim that Samia Hassan Suluhu would be the first female president in East Africa is FALSE. Burundi, Mauritius, Ethiopia and Malawi had produced female president before her.

Does viral photo show Assistant Commissioner of Police arrested?

0

ON March 12, 2021, Soludo Diaso @SDiaso, shared a photo of a man wearing a Police uniform and several other men sitting on the floor with the caption that it shows an Assistant Commissioner of Police  (ACP) in Nigeria arrested for kidnapping. 

The post which generated over 11,000 engagements did not state the identity of the supposed Police officer.

THE CLAIM

The photo shows an Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) in Nigeria arrested for kidnapping.

The false claim as it appears on Twitter.

THE FINDINGS

Findings by the FactCheckHub show that the claim is FALSE.

Using the TinEye Reverse Image Search, the photograph was traced to 2019.

A search using the Google Reverse Image tool in 0.79 seconds produced 295 search results.

From the search results, there was a news report that gave the suspect’s identity as Kingsley Udoyen.

He was arrested on January 2, 2019, for impersonating a senior police officer’s rank of an ACP.

The rank, according to Musa Kimo, a former Commissioner of Police in Akwa Ibom, was used to scam and threaten members of the public.

Kimo told journalists during a media briefing in the state that:

A search in his house led to the discovery of one English pistol without magazine and ammunition, portraits of the Chief Superintendent of Police and Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP), three pairs of uniforms, fake police ID card, and other documents from the suspect.

Frank Mba, the Police Spokesperson, in a statement, also described the accused as an impersonator and a fake police officer.

Mba said:

The suspect in Police uniform with the rank of an Assistant Commissioner of Police, one Kingsley Udoyen, male, 56years of No. 3, Stadium Road, Abak, Akwa Ibom State (see attached picture), is a fake Police Officer and not a serving Assistant Commissioner of Police.

Udoyen was later charged at the Magistrate Court, Abak in Akwa Ibom state.

This photo with a similar caption has been fact-checked and debunked in 2019 before resurfacing online in 2021.

This led the Police to debunk it on their verified social media account.

THE VERDICT

The claim that the photo shows an Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) in  Nigeria arrested for kidnapping is FALSE.

 

Burna Boy, Wizkid NOT the first Nigerians to win Grammy

0

VIRAL posts on Sunday, March 14, 2021 claimed that Nigerian artistes, Damini Ebunoluwa Ogulu popularly known as Burna Boy and Ayodeji Ibrahim Balogun popularly known as Wizkid were the first Nigerians to bag the Grammy Award.

A Twitter user, Ibe with the username @meettheRichard tweeted that Burna Boy is the first Nigerian Artist ever to win the Grammy.

 

His tweet read:

[sic] Burna Boy becomes the first Nigerian Artist ever to win #GRAMMYs for their original work. This is just the beginning of more things to come! E choke!”

As at 12 noon of Monday, March 15, 2021 the tweet had already garnered 1,247 likes and 249 retweets.

A separate blog post, on the same day, also claimed that Wizkid is the first Nigerian to win the Grammy Award. The headline reads:

BREAKING!!! Wizkid becomes the first Nigerian to win a ‘Grammy Award’.

THE CLAIM

Burna Boy and Wizkid are the first Nigerians to win the Grammy Award.

A tweet claiming Burna Boy is the first Nigerian to win the Grammy.

THE FINDINGS

The Grammy Award, otherwise known as Grammy, is an award presented by the Recording Academy to recognise achievements in the global music industry.

The first edition of the award held on May 4, 1959, with its latest edition, the 63rd edition held on Sunday, March 14, 2021.

Two Nigerians, Damini Ebunoluwa Ogulu popularly known as Burna Boy and Ayodeji Ibrahim Balogun popularly known as Wizkid were part of those that won at the 63rd edition.

Burna Boy won ‘Best Global Music Album’ for his album  Twice as Tall, while Wizkid together with Beyoncé, and Blue Ivy won ‘Best Music Video’ for the song Brown Skin Girl.

The FactCheckHub findings revealed that although Burna Boy and Wizkid won at the 63rd Grammy, the duo were not the first Nigerians to win a Grammy.

A blog post claiming Wizkid is the first Nigerian to win the Grammy.

In 1991,  Sikiru Adepoju and Babatunde Olatunji won a Grammy for their work in the album Planet Drum produced by Mickey Hart which won the Best World Music Album category.

In 2009, jazz percussionist, Olalekan Babalola, won a Grammy for his work on Ali Farka Toure’s In the Heart of the Moon album.

Babalola also  won a second Grammy in 2006 for his work on Cassandra Wilson’s album titled Loverly 

Also, artistes of Nigerian descent like beatboxer, Kevin Olusola; rapper, Chamillionaire; singer, Seal have all won the Grammy.

Sade Adu who is also of Nigerian descent and was born in Nigeria won her Grammy in 1985 for the Best New Artiste category.

She also won Grammy in other categories in 1993, 2001 and 2010.

THE VERDICT

The claim that Burna Boy and Wizkid were the first Nigerians to win Grammy is FALSE. Nigerians and artistes of Nigerian descent have at different points in time won the Grammy Award prior to 2021.

Has North Korean President, Kim Jong-Un, been contesting unopposed?

0

A viral post on Twitter claimed that the North Korean president, Kim Jong-un, has been the only one appearing on ballot despite the country holding regular elections.

The post was tweeted by a Twitter page named Myth and Fact with the twitter ID @MythAndFact

“Elections are held in North Korea every 4 to 5 years but Kim Jong-Un is the only person on the ballot,” the tweet read.

THE CLAIM

From the claim the following claims were established:

  1. Elections are held in North Korea every 4 to 5 years.
  2. Kim Jong-Un has been contesting unopposed.
The claim on Twitter.

THE FINDINGS

CLAIM 1: Are elections held in North Korea every 4 to 5 years?

Report shows that the claim is true.

In 2014, the Independent, a British newspaper reported that elections in North Korea is held every five years.

The FactCheckHub findings show that the first election after Kim Jong-Un took over from his father was in 2014.

He was later reelected in 2019, which is five years later.

CLAIM 2: Kim Jong-Un has been contesting unopposed

Report shows that the claim is true.

North Korea analyst Fyodor Tertitskiy, who is based in the South Korean capital Seoul told the BBC that only one candidate is on the ballot paper.

He explained that once it’s your turn,  you receive a ballot paper with just one name on it. There’s nothing to fill in, no boxes to tick. You take that paper and put it into the ballot box, which is located in the open.

He also clarifies that, even though there is only a name on the ballot paper , there are actually three different factions in parliament, “The Workers Party, of which Kim Jong-un is the chairman, is by far the biggest but a few seats are usually held by two other parties, the Social Democratic party and the Chondoist Chongu party”.

The Independent report and another BBC report  also put forward that only state approved candidate are placed on the ballot.

THE VERDICT

The claim that election in North Korea is held every 4 to 5 years is TRUE.  The election usually have a 5-year interval.

The claim that Kim Jong-Un has been contesting unopposed is also TRUE.

Viral photo of cattle eating tomatoes is from India, not Nigeria

ON March 4, 2021, an image posted by a blog showed cattle eating from a tomato heap by the roadside.

The blog noted that these tomatoes are loss incurred by farmers in the northern part of Nigeria.

The blog wrote:

[SIC] As the blockade of food items from the north to the south continued some traders from the north have continued to count their loses.

[SIC] Here are photo of spoil Tomatoes throw away along the road after been intercepted for days without able to move to the south.

This image with similar implied and explicit captions was also posted by different persons; here and here.

THE CLAIM

That the image shows cattle eating tomatoes from farmers in the North who couldn’t supply to the southern part of Nigeria.

The claim that cattle eat tomatoes owned by farmers in the north as it appears on a blog.

THE FINDINGS

Findings by The FactCheckHub show that the claim is FALSE.

CONTEXT: Following an ethnic crisis between the Hausa and Yoruba in Shasha, Oyo State, which also resulted in the loss of lives and properties, some northern traders under the Amalgamated Union of Food Stuff and Cattle Dealers of Nigeria resolved to suspend the transportation of farm produce to southern parts of Nigeria.

Trailers loaded with cattle, onions, tomatoes, and other farm produce were stopped from entering Jebba, a border town between Kwara and Niger States of the country.

In a report, the Union said it embarked on the action as a form of protest against the alleged killings of its members residing in other parts of Nigeria.

“There is a task force that we set up to enforce the directive by the union that there would be no transportation of cattle and foodstuffs to the South with effect from Thursday. So, the union set up the task force to prevent sabotage,” Kabiru Salisu, the Union’s financial secretary stated.”

The incident had since generated reactions on the internet with people in support and against the move.

Does the image depicts cattle eating tomatoes owned by farmers from northern Nigeria?

A search conducted by The FactCheckHub using the reverse image search traced the image to  2013  where it was published by a Hindi newspaper.

It was traced to Barwani District, in Madhya Pradesh, India.

According to the report, “a campaign to make agriculture a profitable business is going on in Madhya Pradesh, but tomato farming is proving to be the biggest loss-making business to the farmers of Barwani. The situation is that farmers are not even getting the cost price of tomatoes. They eventually threw tomatoes on the streets.”

After then, the image has appeared on the internet in July 2017.

Therefore, this cannot be an image of an incident that is stated to have happened in Nigeria in the year 2021.

THE VERDICT

The claim that the image shows cattle eating tomatoes from farmers in the North who couldn’t supply to the southern part of Nigeria is FALSE. The image has been online since 2013 and it is from India.